AUTOHISTORIOGRAPHY OF THE SOVIET SCHOLAR: V. V. STRUVE'S LETTER TO THE EDITOR OF VDI
Table of contents
Share
QR
Metrics
AUTOHISTORIOGRAPHY OF THE SOVIET SCHOLAR: V. V. STRUVE'S LETTER TO THE EDITOR OF VDI
Annotation
PII
S0321-03910000339-8-1
DOI
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Pages
778-795
Abstract
In this article, I provide an edition of Vasiliy Struve's letter to the Editor of the VDI (Journal of Ancient History) with his objections against the proofreading of the article “Producers of wealth in the royal household of the third dynasty of Ur” (1954) by Alexander Tumenev. This letter gives us an example of a self-historiography of a Soviet historian and his confession about the birth of his main conception and its defense from the criticism of his colleagues.
Keywords
V.V. Struve, A.I. Tumenev, Soviet historiography, Sumer, Vesinik drevney istorii
Number of purchasers
4
Views
657
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Cite Download pdf

References



Additional sources and materials


Diakonoff, I.M. 1939: [Letter to the Sumerian king Shu-sin (on the issue of land relations in Sumer)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 59–64.
D'yakonov, I.M. Pis'mo k shumerskomu tsaryu Shu-Sinu (k voprosu o zemel'nykh otnosheniyakh v Shumere). VDI 1, 59–64.
Diakonoff, I.M. 1958: [Work with Sumerian historical sources]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 48–69.
D'yakonov, I.M. O rabote s shumerskimi istoricheskimi istochnikami VDI 2, 48–69.
Izvestiya GAIMK 1934: Izvestiya Gosudarstvennoy Akademii Istorii Material’noy Kul’tury. Vyp. 77 [Proceedings of the National Academy of the History of Material Culture. Issue 77]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Izvestiya Gosudarstvennoj Akademii Istorii Material'noj Kul'tury. Vyp. 77. M. – L.
Krikh, S.B. 2015: [How not to write a major work of all your life; a case of academician V.V. Struve]. Mir istorika [World of Historian] 10, 241–273.
Krikh, S.B. Kak ne napisat' trud vsej zhizni: sluchaj akademika V.V. Struve. Mir istorika 10, 241–273.
Krikh, S.B. 2016: [I.M. Diakonoff vs V.V. Struve: polemics in the fields of Sumer]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 76/4, 1013–1031.
Krikh, S.B. I.M. D'yakonov protiv V.V. Struve: polemika na polyakh Shumera. VDI 76/4, 1013–1031.
Legrain, L. 1951: Ur Excavations. Vol. X. Seal Cylinders. London–Philadelphia.
Nikolsky, N.M. 1934: [On the question of slavery in the Ancient East]. Problemy istorii dokapitalisticheskikh obshchestv [Problems of the History of Precapitalist Societies] 7–8, 207–210.
Nikol'skij, N.M. K voprosu o rabstve na drevnem Vostoke (po povodu stat'i V.V. Struve «Rabovladel'cheskaya latifundiya v Sumire III dinastii Ura», S.F. Ol'denburgu. K 50-letiyu nauchno-obschestvennoj deyatel'nosti 1882–1932 gg., Sbornik statej, L., Izd. AN SSSR, 1934 g.). Problemy istorii dokapitalisticheskikh obschestv 7–8, 207–210.
Nikolsky, N.M. 1941: [Slavery in ancient Mesopotamia]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History]. 1, 45–63.
Nikol'skij, N.M. Rabstvo v drevnem Dvurech'e. VDI 1, 45–63.
Oldenburg, S.F. 1931: Vostok i Zapad v sovetskikh usloviyakh [East and West in Soviet Conditions]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Ol'denburg, S.F. Vostok i Zapad v sovetskikh usloviyakh. M. – L.
Riftin, A.P. 1937: Staro-vavilonskie dokumenty v sobraniyakh SSSR [Old Babylonian Documents in the Soviet Union Collections]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Riftin, A.P. Staro-vavilonskie dokumenty v sobraniyakh SSSR. M. – L.
Struve, V.V. 1934a: [Once again on the slave latifundium in the Ur III Sumer (response to N.M. Nikolsky)]. Problemy istorii dokapitalisticheskikh obshchestv [Problems of the History of Precapitalist Societies] 7–8, 211–222.
Struve, V.V. Esche raz o rabovladel'cheskoj latifundii Sumira III dinastii Ura (otvet N.M. Nikol'skomu). Problemy istorii dokapitalisticheskikh obschestv 7–8, 211–222.
Struve, V.V. 1934b: Istoriya drevnego Vostoka. Kratkiy kurs [The History of the Ancient East. Short Course]. Moscow.
Struve, V.V. Istoriya drevnego Vostoka. Kratkij kurs. M.
Struve, V.V. 1934s: [For ‘salary’ semantics]. In: Yazyk i myshlenie: sbornik statey [Language and Thought: Collection of Articles] III–IV. Moscow–Leningrad, 101–110.
Struve, V.V. K semantike zhalovan'ya. V sb.: Yazyk i myshlenie: sbornik statej III–IV. M. – L., 101–110.
Struve, V.V. 1934d: Ocherki sotsial’no-ekonomicheskoy istorii drevnego Vostoka [Essays on the Social and Economic History of the Ancient East]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Struve, V.V. Ocherki sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskoj istorii drevnego Vostoka. (Izvestiya GAIMK, 97). M. – L.
Struve, V.V. 1934e: [Slave-holding latifundium in the Ur III Sumer (ca. 23th cent. B.C.E.)]. Sergeyu Fedorovichu Oldenburgu. K pyatidesyatiletiyu nauchno-obshchestvennoy deyatel’nosti. 1882–1932: sbornik statey [S.F. Oldenburg. On the 50th Anniversary of the Scientific and Social Activities. 1882–1932: Collection of Papers]. Leningrad, 495–507.
Struve, V.V. Rabovladel'cheskaya latifundiya v Sumire III dinastii Ura (ok. XXIII v. do n.eh.). Sergeyu Fedorovichu Ol'denburgu. K pyatidesyatiletiyu nauchno-obschestvennoj deyatel'nosti. 1882–1932: sbornik statej L., 495–507.
Struve, V.V. 1934f: [The rudiment of class indicator in the Sumerian language]. Izvestiya Akademii nauk SSSR. Otdelenie obshchestvennykh nauk [Proceedings of the USSR Academy of Sciences. Department of Social Sciences] 10, 799–806.
Struve, V.V. Rudiment klassovogo pokazatelya v sumerijskom yazyke. Izvestiya Akademii nauk SSSR. Otdelenie obschestvennykh nauk 10, 799–806.
Struve, V.V. 1936a: Istoriya drevnego mira. T.I. Drevniy Vostok [History of the Ancient World. Vol. I. Ancient East]. Moscow.
[Struve, V.V.] Istoriya drevnego mira. T.I. Drevnij Vostok. M.
Struve, V.V. 1936b: Khrestomatiya po drevney istorii. Posobie dlya prepodavateley sredney shkoly. T. I [Reader in Ancient History. Guide for Secondary School Teachers]. Moscow.
Struve, V.V. Khrestomatiya po drevnej istorii. Posobie dlya prepodavatelej srednej shkoly. Pod red. V.V. Struve. Tom I. M.
Struve, V.V. 1940: [Marx’s definition of early class society]. Sovetskaya etnografiya. Sbornik statey [Soviet Ethnography. Collection of Articles] III. Moscow – Leningrad, 5–22.
Struve, V.V. Marksovo opredelenie ranneklassovogo obschestva. Sovetskaya ehtnografiya. Sbornik statej. III. M. – L., 5–22.
Struve, V.V. 1941: Istoriya drevnego Vostoka [The History of the Ancient East]. Leningrad.
Struve, V.V. Istoriya drevnego Vostoka L.
Struve, V.V. 1947: [The social structure of the South Mesopotamia in the Ur III times (2132–2024 B.C.E.)]. Yubileynyy sbornik, posvyashchennyy 30-letiyu Velikoy Oktiabr’skoy sotsialisticheskoy revolyutsii [Collection of Articles to the 30th Anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolution]. Vol. 2. Moscow – Leningrad, 720–742.
Struve, V.V. Obschestvennyj stroj Yuzhnogo Mezhdurech'ya v ehpokhu III dinastii Ura (2132–2024 gg. do n.eh.). Yubilejnyj sbornik, posvyaschennyj 30-letiyu Velikoj Oktyabr'skoj sotsialisticheskoj revolyutsii. T. 2. M. – L., 720–742.
Struve, V.V. 1949: [New data on the organization of labor and social structure in the Ur III Sumer]. Sovetskoe vostokovedenie [Soviet Oriental Studies] VI, 149–184.
Struve, V.V. Novye dannye ob organizatsii truda i sotsial'noj strukture obschestva Sumera ehpokhi III dinastii Ura. Sovetskoe vostokovedenie VI, 149–184.
Tumenev, A.I. 1929: [Individualizing and generalizing methods in historical science]. Istorik-marksist [Marxist Historian] 12, 153–184.
Tyumenev, A.I. Individualiziruyuschij i generaliziruyuschij metody v istoricheskoj nauke. Istorik-marksist 12, 153–184.
Tumenev, A.I. 1935: Istoriya antichnykh rabovladel’cheskikh obshchestv [The History of the Ancient Slaveholding Societies]. Moscow–Leningrad.
Tyumenev, A.I. Istoriya antichnykh rabovladel'cheskikh obschestv. M. – L.
Tumenev, A.I. 1946: [The significance of the term ‘kal’ in Sumerian language]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 10–20.
Tyumenev, A.I. O znachenii termina «kal» v drevneshumerskom yazyke. VDI 2, 10–20.
Tumenev, A.I. 1954: [Producers of wealth in the royal household of the third dynasty of Ur]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 10–32.
Tyumenev, A.I. Proizvoditeli material'nykh blag v tsarskom khozyajstve vremeni tret'ej dinastii Ura. VDI 1, 10–32.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate