Везде
Vladimir Solovyov and Joseph de Maistre
Table of contents
Annotation Estimate Publication content
References Comments
Share
QR
Metrics
Vladimir Solovyov and Joseph de Maistre
Annotation
PII
S004287440005743-2-
DOI
10.31857/S004287440005743-2
Publication type
Article
Status
Published
Authors
Vadim Parsamov 
Affiliation: National Research University "Higher School of Economics"
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Edition
Issue 7
Pages
175-187
Abstract

Solovyov’s attitude to Joseph de Mestre is striking in its paradox. The name of this bright and convinced propagandist of Catholicism is absent from the works of Solovyov on the Catholic Church, and unexpectedly appears in the article “Slavophilism and its degeneration”. In this article, Mestre is presented as a teacher of Slavophiles, for whom the attractiveness of his political conservatism overshadowed an unacceptable for them religious system, sympathy for the Jesuits, and even hostility towards the Russian people and their religion. For Solovyov this is one of the evidence of the inconsistency of the Slavophil doctrine. At the same time, Soloviev does not himself establish a genetic link between the Mestre and the late Slavophiles, but merely cites the thoughts from the article of the writer of the Slavophile direction P.A. Matveyev. Further acquaintance with the works of Mestre allowed Solovyov to formulate his own critical attitude to his ideas. Despite a number of coincidences in relation to Catholicism and to Pope, Solovyov actually denied Mestres the right to be considered a Christian thinker because of his positive attitude towards the death penalty and the idealization of the executioner. In this, according to Solovyov, pagan roots features characteristic of the medieval worldview were revealed.

Keywords
V.S. Solovyov, J. de Maistre, Catholicism, papacy, Slavophiles, freedom, personality, society
Received
28.07.2019
Date of publication
28.07.2019
Number of purchasers
89
Views
887
Readers community rating
0.0 (0 votes)
Previous versions
S004287440005743-2-1 Дата внесения правок в статью - 04.07.2019
Cite   Download pdf Download JATS

References

1. Gilyarov-Platonov 1884 – Gilyarov-Platonov N.P. Otkuda nigilizm // Rus'. 1884. №24. 15 dekabrya. S. 13–26 [Gilyarov-Platonov, Nikita P. Where nihilism (In Russian)].

2. Matveev 1889a – P. M-ev'. Zhozef de Mestr i ego politicheskaya doktrina // Russkij vestnik. 1889. № 5. S. 220–238 [Matveev, Pavel A. (1889) Joseph de Mestre and his political doctrine (In Russian)].

3. Matveev 1889b – P. M-ev'. Zhozef de Mestr i ego politicheskaya doktrina // Russkij vestnik. 1889. № 6. S. 74–95 [Matveev, Pavel A. (1889) Joseph de Mestre and his political doctrine Russkiy Vestnik, Part II, In Russian].

4. Mestr 1998 – Mestr Zh. de. Sankt-Peterburgskie vechera. SPb.: Aletejya, 1998 [Maistre, Joseph de (1821) Les Soirees St. De Saint-Petersbourg, (Russian Translation 1998)].

5. Solov'ev 1966a – Solov'ev V.S. Velikij spor i khristianskaya politika // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 4. S. 3–242. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Great Debate and Christian Politics ((In Russian)].

6. Solov'ev 1966b – Solov'ev V.S. Istoriya i buduschnost' teokratii // Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 4. S. 76–102. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S.]

7. Solov'ev 1966v – Solov'ev V.S. Slavyanskij vopros // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 5. S. 58–74. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Slawdom’s Question (In Russian)].

8. Solov'ev 1966g – Solov'ev V.S. Slavyanofil'stvo i ego vyrozhdenie // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 5. S. 181–244. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Slavophilism and its Degeneration (In Russian)].

9. Solov'ev 1966d – Solov'ev V.S. Ob upadke srednevekovogo mirosozertsaniya // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 6. S. 381––393. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S.]

10. Solov'ev 1966e – Solov'ev V.S. Pravo i nravstvennost' // Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 8. S. 519–Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Law and Morality (In Russian)].

11. Colov'ev 1966zh – Solov'ev V.S. Ideya chelovechestva u Avgusta Konta // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 9. S. 172–193. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Manhood Idea at Auguste Caumte (In Rissian)].

12. Colov'ev 1966z – Solov'ev V.S. Mehstr // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 10. S. 429–435. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Maistre, Joseph de (in Russian)].

13. Colov'ev 1966i – Solov'ev V.S. Vladimir Svyatoj i khristianskoe gosudarstvo // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 11. S. 121–138. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Vladimir Saint and Christian State (in Russian)].

14. Colov'ev 1966k – Solov'ev V.S. Russkaya ideya // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 11. S. 90–120. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Russian Idea (in Russian)].

15. Colov'ev 1966l – Solov'ev V.S. Rossiya i Vselenskaya tserkov' // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 11. S. 139–348. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1966 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Russia and Universal Church (in Russian)].

16. Colov'ev 1966m – Solov'ev V.S. Pis'mo imperatoru Nikolayu II // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 11. S. 452–456[Solovyov, Vladimir Letter to Emperor Nicholas II (in Russian)]..

17. Colov'ev 1966n – Solov'ev V.S. Retsenziya na knigu E.N. Trubetskogo «Religiozno-obschestvennyj ideal zapadnogo khristianstva v XI veke» // Solov'ev V.S. Sobranie sochinenij v dvenadtsati tomakh. T. 12. S. 351–355[Solovyov, Vladimir S. Russia and Universal Church (in Russian)]..

18. Solov'ev 1970a – Solov'ev V.S. Pis'mo I.S. Aksakovu v fevrale 1883 g. // Solov'ev V.S. Pis'ma v chetyrekh tomakh. T.4. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom». S. 19–20 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Letter to I. S. Aksakov, February 1883, (in Russian)].

19. Solov'ev 1970b – Solov'ev V.S. Pis'mo bratu M.S. Solov'evu ot marta 1887 g. // Solov'ev V.S. Pis'ma v chetyrekh tomakh. T.4. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1970. S. 106–108 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Letter to Brother, M.S. Solovyov, March 1887 (in Russian)]

20. Solov'ev 1970v – Solov'ev V.S. Pis'mo J.Yu. Shtrosmajeru, 21 sentyabrya 1886 // Solov'ev V.S. Pis'ma v chetyrekh tomakh. T.1. Bryussel': «Zhizn' s Bogom», 1970. C. 183–190 [Solovyov, Vladimir S. Letter to J. Strossmayer, 21 September, 1868 (Russian Translation)].

21. Chaadaev 1991 – Chaadaev P.Ya. Polnoe sobranie sochinenij i izbrannye pis'ma. T.1. M.: Nauka, 1991 [Chaadayev, P.Ya. Complete works and Selected Letters. In Russian].

22. Bergeret 1888 – Bergeret Gaston Principes de politique. Essais sur l’objet, la methode et la forme des divers gouvernements l’organisation des peuples et les theories de la souverainete avec apercu des principales quetions constitutionnelles. Paris: Libraire illustree, [1888]

23. Maistre 1884 – Maistre J. de. Du pape // Oeuvres completes. T.2. Lyon, 1884

24. Alyaev 2016 – Alyaev G.E. Ideya Vselenskoj tserkvi i «katolitsizm» Vl. Solov'eva v vospriyatii i tvorchestve pozdnego S. Franka // Solov'evskie issledovaniya. 2016. Vyp. 2(50) Ivanovo: IGEhU. S. 114–132.

25. Gavrilov 1999 – Gavrilov M. Byl li Solov'ev katolikom ili pravoslavnym? // Simvol=Symbol. Parizh, 1999. № 41. S.289–315.

26. Gajdenko 2001 – Gajdenko P.P. Vladimir Solov'ev i filosofiya Serebryanogo veka. M.: Progress-Traditsiya, 2001.

27. Glod 2012 – Glot P. Zhozef de Mestr i Lui Bonal'd. Kontrrevolyutsionnye mysliteli: skhodstva i razlichiya // Aktual'nost' Zhozefe de Mestra. Materialy rosijsko-frantsuzskoj konferentsii. M.: RGGU, 2012. S. 31–50.

28. Kantor 2004 – Kantor V.K. Vladimir Solov'ev: imperskie problemy vsemirnoj teokratii // Voprosy filosofii. 2004. № 4. S. 126–144.

29. Kantor 2007 – Kantor V.K. Sankt-Peterburg: Rossijskaya imperiya protiv rossijskogo khaosa. M.: Rosspehn, 2007.

30. Kantor 2010 – Kantor V.K. Vladimir Solov'ev o soblazne natsionalizma // Solov'evskie issledovaniya. 2004. № 4(28) S. 35–47.

31. Krasitskij 2009 – Krasitskij Yan. Bog, Chelovek i Zlo. Issledovanie filosofii Vladimira Solov'eva. M.: Progress-Traditsiya, 2009.

32. Levitskij 1996 – Levitskij S.A. Ocherki po istorii russkoj filosofii M.: Kanon, 1996.

33. Losev A.F. 1990 – Losev A.F. Vladimir Solov'ev i ego vremya. M.: Progress, 1990.

34. Myuller 2000 – Myuller L. Ponyat' Rossiyu: istoriko-kul'turnye issledovaniya. M.: Progress-Traditsiya, 2000.

35. Pruayar 1993 – Pruayar de Zh. Vladimir Solov'ev o Rimsko-katolicheskoj Tserkvi // Novaya Evropa. № 2. 1993. S. 59–78.

Comments

No posts found

Write a review
Translate